CLARIFICATION: [psychiatry] is a uniquely harmful pseudoscience that ruins many people’s lives which makes choosing to ignore the harm it’s capable of doing inexcusable.

Report comment

“Neither an Eeyore nor a Tigger be.”

“The Overselling of Gratitude — Always being positive makes no more sense than always being negative”, by Alfie Kohn in Psychology Today

Report comment

They should ask themselves why they feel the need to see themselves as a healer, or more precisely, why they feel the need to have others see them as a healer.

In other words, most often in jobs like this it’s the wounded ego that’s in charge, not ‘the wounded healer’ they may (pretentiously) declare themselves to be.

IMHO.

Report comment

Elizabeth, I do not see myself as a victim and for you to suggest that I do is very offensive. Expressing displeasure does not equal victimhood; it indicates quite the opposite.

Please remember that you do not know me outside of this forum, a forum that I am very grateful for because it does not shut people down for speaking the truth as they see it no matter how uncomfortable for others, which is the only way that real change (and healing) can occur.

I’m sorry you have been through so much but am delighted you have made so much progress and I hope you continue doing so.

Report comment

Hi Birdsong, I already experienced iatragenic harm and recovered. I’m about 90% fully recovered, and still have some trauma to work through.
It’s taken years me years… about 10+ so far.
However, I prefer to focus on gratitude for the recovery I have achieved, and for the practitioners who are willing to take responsibility for their harm, and the practitioners who have helped me along the way, primarily herbalists and true healers who have done the work themselves.

I have been through forced psychiatric drugging and physical restraint. I have been through 15 hospitalizations and psychiatric holds, experimented on by doctors and the mental health system as a whole. I literally should be dead right now. I was not supposed to be able to heal or get off of any medication. But I’m med-free and my brain works pretty good.

I choose gratitude. I can spend my whole life focusing on how I was harmed, but I am not a victim anymore. I was. But I don’t want to live the rest of my life that way. I couldn’t heal if I didn’t choose to change my perspective on life and how I relate to the world. That changed my brain and helped me heal more than anything else.

I am sorry for what you have been through. I wish you hope and healing.

Report comment

P.S. I will say this: Florian seems to be an unusually self-reflective person with enough integrity to not only stop practicing psychiatry but to call it out publicly for what it actually is: a uniquely destructive pseudoscience that ruins many people’s lives. And for that I, too, am grateful.

Report comment

CLARIFICATION: …stories like this are good at shedding light on what the purpose of psychiatry really is: a way of denying the reality of the inner healer within each human being.

Report comment

CLARIFICATION: …unconscious patterns that have ‘clinicians’ wrongly believing their INDOCTRINATION makes them indispensable.

Report comment

I have two questions for you: How grateful would you be if the “medications” you were prescribed had caused you significant iatrogenic harm? How grateful would you be if you were hospitalized and drugged against your will? Because in case you don’t know, that’s the unjust reality facing more than a few people, and hypothetically ANYONE who happens to fall into the hands of a psychiatrist at an inopportune moment in their life.

Sugarcoating reality is an insult to the people who’ve been harmed by psychiatry, and no one harmed by psychiatry needs to be preached to.

Maybe you should consider that before you start singing kumbaya.

Report comment

I am impressed. A psychiatrist who is doing the work. I appreciate your story and willingness to share, especially on this platform.

I have unconsciously believed psychiatrists are monsters for all of my life. I didn’t realize how afraid I truly was until I caught myself freezing up when I had to go to an appointment last year. My last appointment in the spring of 2023, I felt anxiety by having to sit next to my nurturing and kind trans psychiatrist as she spoke of women’s circles and her respect for me as I could “manage my life/moods” without a mood stabilizer. I got my last prescription for Trazadone, and I am now med free.

I hope you share your healing journey within the psychiatric community. More practitioners could benefit from what you learned about yourself. You could save the lives of patients by educating psychiatrists. Just a thought.

I am grateful for your share. I am grateful that you are doing the difficult work of healing. I have respect for you, even if the small part of me still fears psychiatry.

I look forward to reading The Alchemy of Healing. I love Jung as well.

With gratitude —
Elisabeth, Integrative Health Coach
@wildmoonfeather

Report comment

…and stories like this are good at showing what the purpose of psychiatry really is: a way of denying the reality of one’s own and others spiritualty.

Report comment

…the biggest being an ability to project unconscious feelings and impulses onto ‘clients’ by way of so-called ‘diagnosis’, which, btw, means never having to face their own demons…

Report comment

Like any other cult, deprogramming from psychiatry’s omnipresent narrative can be extremely challenging in a culture with an overreliance on ‘experts’, many of whom know diddly squat about themselves or the pontifical world they inhabit. And goodness knows playing the guru has its advantages…

Report comment

There’s so much wrong with the “mental health system” it’s hard to know where to begin. But unconscious patterns are where to begin, unconscious patterns that have people wrongly believing they’re “ill” for struggling emotionally, and unconscious patterns that have “clinicians” wrongly believing their “training” makes them indispensable.

However, I definitely think most psych professionals are far more unconscious that any of their “clients”, because to me it seems the “clinician’s” inauthenticity is what keeps the system running the way it does, which is inauthentically.

It’s basically a power struggle that’s as old as time. IMHO.

Report comment

Report comment

Speak for yourself. An apology from psychiatry isn’t enough if their “treatments” have harmed a person’s ability to provide for themselves financially.

Report comment

Report comment

There are so few psychiatrists who will apologize for the harm the DSM deluded psychiatric and psychologic industries are systemically doing. Thank you for apologizing.

And I agree, Jung’s theology is likely closest to the truth. I’ve got my own, wounded researcher and truth sharer, story … and it is about equating my conscious and unconscious selves. Ironically, brought about by being slowly weaned off the psych drugs, by my former psychiatrist.

Thank God, for the psychiatrists who are actually slowly, and with respect for their patients’ opinions, weaning people off the psych drugs.

Report comment

Report comment